Brother against Brother: Early Refutation of Wahhabism by the 18th-century Hanbali Scholars
Main Article Content
Abstract
Wahhabism has been a source of intergenerational controversies among sunnī madhabī scholars and even among respected Hanbali scholars themselves, initially from its rise in the 18th century until the date. Muḥammad b. ‘Abd al-Wahhāb’s fatwas have drawn sharp critiques and refutations by Hanbali scholars, particularly those regarding tawḥīd ulūhiyyat, which justifies declaring others as infidel-apostates (kāfir murtadd). Other contested fatwas include those on Muslim practices of seeking blessings (tabarruk), seeking intermediaries (tawassul), visiting graves (ziyārat), and seeking help (istighāthah). Muḥammad b. ‘Abd al-Wahhāb and his followers have theologically deemed these practices of major idolatry (as-shirk al-akbar) and have erred and biased in proclaiming his Wahhabism as the true successor to Ibnu Taymiyya, Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya and even manhaj of Ahmad b. Hanbal. In this regard, this article portrays the refutations and rebuttals by Hanbali scholars of Muḥammad b. ‘Abd al-Wahhāb and his early Wahhabism based on primary sources. The discussion describes theological examinations and counter-narrative campaigns against Wahhabism initiated by the 18th-century Hanbali scholars. The findings show that the majority of Hanbali scholars at the time refuse the teachings of Wahhabism and argue that the fatwas of Wahhabi scholars on the notion of ulūhiyyat, tabarruk, tawassul, ziyārat, and istigāthah are irrelevant and disconnected from the intellectualism of Hanbali scholars.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
References
Abdad, M. Zaidi. “Analisis Dan Pemetaan Pemikiran Fikih Moderat Di Timur Tengah Dan Relasinya Dengan Gerakan Fikih Formalis.” ESENSIA: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin 12, no. 1 (January 22, 2011): 39–62.
‘Abīd, Abū Badr Muḥammad bin Bakr bin Ibrāhīm Ālū. Manhaj al-Imām Muḥammad bin ‘Abd Al-Wahhāb fī Tadabburi al-Qurān. Mecca: Maktaba al-Furqān, 2011.
Al-Ḥaddād, Al-Ḥabīb ‘Alawī bin Aḥmad bin Ḥasan bin Quṭb al-Ḥabīb ‘Abd Allāh bin ‘Alawī. Miṣbāh Al-Anām Wa Jalā’u al-Ḍalām Fī Radd Shubahi al-Bida‘i al-Najdī allatī Adhalla Bihā al-A‘wām. Istanbul: Maktabah Ḥaqīqah, 2014.
Al-Ḥanbalī, Ibnu Ḥumaid al-Najdī. Al-Suḥub al-Wābilah ‘Alā Ḍarā’Iḥa al-Ḥanābilah. Mecca: Maṭba‘ah al-Imām Aḥmad, 1996.
‘Alī, ‘Abd Allāh Muḥammad. Mu‘Jam al-Mu’Allifāt al-Islāmiyyah Fī al-Radd ‘alā al-Firqah al-Wahhābiyyah. Beirut: Markaz al-Zahrā’ al-Islāmī, 1430.
Al-‘Imād, ‘Iṣām Yaḥyā ‘Alī. Naqd Muḥammad Bin ‘Abd al-Wahhāb Min al-Dakhīl. Mecca: Manshūrāt al-Ijtihād al-Muqaddasah, 2008.
Al-Jawziyya, Ibnu al-Qayyim. I‘lāmu al-Muwaqqi’īn ‘an Rabb al-’Ālamīn. Edited by Abū ‘Ubaidah. Riyad: Dār Ibnu al-Jawzī, 1423.
Al-Rūmī, ‘Abd al-‘Azīs bin Zaid, Muḥammad Baltajī, and Sayyid Ḥijāb. Majmū‘āt Muallifāt Muḥammad Bin ‘Abd Al-Wahhāb: Hādhihi Masā’Il Lakhiṣahā Muḥammad Bin ‘Abd Al-Wahhāb Min Kalāmi Shaykh al-Islām Aḥmad Bin ‘Abd al-Ḥalīm Bin ‘Abd al-Salām Ibnu Taymiyyah. Daḥnah Manṭiqah al-Qaṣīm: al-Maktabah al-Sa‘ūdiyyah, 1978.
Al-Ṣa’īdī, ‘Abd Muta‘ālī. Al-Mujaddidūn Fī al-Islām Min al-Qarni al-Awwal Ilā al-Rabi‘ ‘Ashar. Cairo: Maktabah al-Adab, 1996.
Ālū al-Shaykh, ‘Abd al-Raḥmān bin Ḥasan. Fatḥ Al-Majīd Li Sharḥ Kitāb al-Tawḥīd. Edited by al-Walīd bin ‘Abd al-Raḥmān Ālū Fariyyān. 8th ed. Riyad: Dār al-Muayyad, 2002.
Ālū Bassām, ‘Abd Allāh bin ‘Abd al-Raḥmān bin Ṣāliḥ. Ḥizānah al-Tawārikh al-Najdiyyah. Vol. 1. Riyad: Dār al-Jayl, 1414.
———. ‘Ulamā’ Najd Khilāla Tsamāniyyat Qurūn. 5 vols. Riyad: Dār al-‘Āṣimah, 1419.
Al-‘Uthaymīn, Muḥammad bin Ṣāliḥ. Silsilah Muallifāt Al-Ibn ‘Uthaymīn: Sharḥ Fī Uṣūl Fī al-Tafsīr. Edited by Muassasah Muḥammad bin Ṣāliḥ Al-‘Uthaymīn al-Khairiyyah. Riyad: Maktabah Malik Fahd, 2013.
———. Uṣūl Fī Al-Tafsīr. Riyad: al-Maktabah al-Islāmiyyah, 2001.
Al-Wahhāb, Muḥammad bin ‘Abd. Al-Jawāhir al-Muḍiyyah Li Mujaddid al-Da‘wah al-Najdiyyah. 1st ed. Egypt: Maṭba‘ah al-Manār, 1931.
———. Al-Rasā’il al-Shakhṣiyyah. Edited by Ṣāliḥ bin Fawzān al-Fawzān. Riyad: al-Mamlakah al-al-‘Arabiyyah Sa’ūdiyyah, 1976.
———. “Al-Risālah al-Rābi‘ah Fī Arba‘i Qawā‘id Li al-Dīn.” In Majmū‘ah al-Tawḥīd al-Najdiyyah, by Muḥammad Rashīd Riḍā. Egypt: Maṭba‘ah al-Manār, 1999.
———. Kashf Al-Shubhāt. Edited by Muḥammad Jibrīl al-Saḥarī. Dammāj: Dār ‘Umar bin al-Khaṭṭāb, 2009.
———. “Kitāb Al-Tawḥīd.” In Al-Durar al-Saniyyah Fī al-Ajwibah al-Najdiyyah, by ‘Abd al-Raḥmān Qāsim al-‘Āṣimī. Vol. 2. 6th ed. Riyad: Maṭba’ah Umm al-Qurā, 1996.
———. Kitāb Al-Tawḥīd Alladhī Huwa Ḥaqq Allāh ‘alā al-‘Abīd. Beirut: Manṣūrat Dār Maktabah al-Ḥayāt, 1970.
Al-Wahhāb, Sulaimān bin ‘Abd. Al-Ṣawā‘iq al-Ilāhiyyah fī al-Radd ‘alā al-Wahhābiyyah. Edited by Ḥusayn Ḥilmī. Istanbul: Ikhlās Vakfi Yayindir, 1979.
———. Al-Ṣawā‘iq al-Ilāhiyyah fī al-Radd ‘alā al-Wahhābiyyah. Edited by al-Sarāwī. 1st ed. Beirut: Dhū al-Faqār, 1998.
———. Faṣl al-Khiṭāb min Kitābi Allāh wa Ḥadīth al-Rasūl wa Kalām al-‘Ulamā’ fī Madhabi Ibn ‘Abd al-Wahhāb. Edited by Lajnah al-‘Ulamā.’ 4th ed. Istanbul: Maktabah Ishiq Kitabevi, 1979.
Arsalān, Amīr Shakīb. “Tārīkh Najd Al-Ḥadīth: Ālū Sa‘ūd Wa Ālū Rashīd.” In Ḥāḍir Al-‘Ālam al-Islāmī, by Lothrop Stoddard, translated by ’Ajjāj Nuwaiḥid. Vol. 4. Egypt: Maṭba‘ah ‘Isā al-Bābī al-Ḥalabī, 1352.
al-‘Āṣimī, ‘Abd al-Raḥmān Qāsim. Al-Durar al-Saniyyah Fī al-Ajwibah al-Najdiyyah. Vol. 1. 5. Riyad: Dār al-Qāsim li al-Nashr, 1976.
———. Al-Durar al-Saniyyah fī al-Ajwibah al-Najdiyyah. Vol. 2. 5. Riyad: Dār al-Qāsim li al-Nashr, 1995.
———. Al-Durar al-Saniyyah fī al-Ajwibah al-Najdiyyah: Kitāb al-Jihād. Vol. 9. 5. Riyad: Dār al-Qāsim li al-Nashr, 1995.
———. Al-Durar al-Saniyyah Fī al-Ajwibah al-Najdiyyah: Majmū‘Ah al-Rasā’Il Wa Masā’il al-‘Ulamā’ Najd al-A‘lām Min ‘Aṣr al- Muhammad Bin ‘Abd al-Wahhab Ilā ‘Aṣrinā Hādhā. Vol. 10. 5. Riyad: Dār al-Qāsim li al-Nashr, 1976.
Atabik, Ahmad. “The Discourse of The Qur’anic Metaphors: The Embryo of Theological Sects Disputes in Comprehending the Holy Qur’an.” ESENSIA: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin 22, no. 1 (July 5, 2021): 45–61.
Bih, Al-Ḥajj Mālik. Al-Ḥaqā’iq al-Islāmiyyah Fī al-Radd ‘Alā al-Mazā’Im al-Wahhābiyyah. Edited by Maḥmūd. Istanbul: Hakikat Kitabevi-Darussefaka, 1986.
Brockelmann, Carl. The History of Islamic People with A Review of Events 1939-1947. Translated by Joel Carmichael and Moshe Perlmann. New York: Capricon Books Edition, 1960.
Bsheer, Rosie. Archive Wars: The Politics of History in Saudi Arabia. California: Stanford University Press, 2020.
Conesa, Pierre. The Saudi Terror Machine: The Truth about Radical Islam and Saudi Arabia Revealed. France: Skyhore Publishing, 2018.
Daḥlān, Aḥmad Zainī. Al-Durar al-Saniyyah Fī al-Radd ’alā al-Wahhābiyyah. Cairo: Dār al-Jawāmi‘ al-Kalim, 1420.
———. Al-Durar al-Saniyyah Fī al-Radd ’alā al-Wahhābiyyah. Edited by Jibrīl Ḥaddād. Damascus: Dār Ghār Ḥirā’ and Maktabah al-Aḥbāb, 1424.
———. Fitnah Wahhābiyyah. Istanbul: Darussefaka, Isik Kitabevi, 1978.
———. Khulāṣah al-Kalām fī Bayāni Umarā’i al-Bilādi al-Ḥarām min Zamāni Sayyidinā al-Nabī Ṣallallāhu ‘Alaihi wa Sallama ilā Waqtinā Hādhā bi al-Tamām. Edited by Muḥammad Fārish al-Shāfi‘ī al-Qāhirī. Mecca: Maṭba‘ah Arḍ al-Ḥaramain, 1935.
Fadl, Khaled Medhat Abou El. The Great Theft: Wrestling Islam from the Extremists. New York: Harper Collins, 2009.
‘Ilyān, Muṣṭafā Ḥamdūn. Al-Ḥanābilah Wa Ikhtilāfuhum Bi al-Salafiyyah al-Mu‘āṣirah Fī al-‘Aqā’Id Wa al-Fiqh Wa al-Taṣawwuf. Cairo: Dār al-Nūr al-Mubīn, 2014.
Noorhayati, Siti Mahmudah, and Ahmad Khoirul Fata. “Exclusive Islam From The Perspective of Ibn Taymiyah.” ESENSIA: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Ushuluddin 18, no. 2 (October 20, 2017): 213–223.
Raḥḥāl, ‘Alā’ al-Dīn Ḥusain. Ma’ālim wa Dhawābiṭ al-Ijtihād ’Inda Shaykh al-Islām Ibnu Taymiyyah. 1st ed. Ardun: Dār al-Nafā’is, 1422.
Schwartz, Stephen. The Two Face of Islam: Saudi Fundamentalism and Its Role in Terrorism. New York: First Anchor Books Edition, 2003.
Taneski, Nenad, and Ferdinand Odjakov. “Militant Islamism, Domestic Terrorism and Macedonian National Security.” Violent Extremism and Radicalization Processes as Driving Factors to Terrorism Threath (2018): 137–154.
Ward, Terrence. The Wahhabi Code: How The Saudis Spread Extremism Globally. New York: Archade Publishing, 2018.
Woodward, Mark. “Islam Nusantara: A Semantic and Symbolic Analysis.” Heritage of Nusantara: International Journal of Religious Literature and Heritage 6 (December 27, 2017): 181.